The figure of the victim

genealogy and argumentative uses

Authors

  • Omar Alejandro Murad UNMDP - CONICET

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.34024/prometeica.2020.21.10257

Keywords:

Victim, Rhetoric, Negationism

Abstract

Nowadays, the figure of victim rules several public interventions of individuals and collectives that not only belong to minorities and subaltern groups, but also it rules institutional, collective and individual discourses, that have a consolidated place in the statu quo. A quick look over this issue discards using this figure as a strategy of agency due to a victim is characterized by its passivity. However, the case is that its use in the public space able to certain prerogatives in the agent that invokes it and, at same time, it puts him or her in a position that is not necessarily characterized by its passivity but, on the contrary, this figure endows to the agent with very specific possibilities of action. Specifically, in this work we propose put into question this point of view considering a few examples of negationism about the character of the victim in such. The negation of the victim through the means of disputing its position by its aggressor attracts our attention a kind of verbal intervention that uses the figure of the victim.

In this work we propose, on the one hand, to historicize this figure making its genealogy based on Rene Girard’s studies about sacrifice and, on the other hand, to analyze rhetorically a few exemplary cases that visibilizes the type of agency that characterize its use. To do that we take examples from history and social sciences literature and the feminism movement.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Aristóteles (2019). El arte de la retórica. EUDEBA. Buenos Aires.

Beristáin, H. (1995). Diccionario de retórica y poética. Porrúa. México D.F.

Blumenberg, H. (2018). Paradigmas para una metaforología. Trotta. Madrid.

Crenzel, E. (2013). El prólogo del Nunca Más y la teoría de los dos demonios. Reflexiones sobre una representación de la violencia política en la Argentina. Contenciosa. Vol. 1 No 1. 1-19.

Fassin, D. (2016). La razón humanitaria. Prometeo. Buenos Aires.

Foucault, M. (1998). Vigilar y castigar. El nacimiento de la prisión. Siglo XXI. Buenos Aires.

Frye, N. (1991). Anatomía de la crítica. Monte Ávila editores. Venezuela.

Girard, R. (2002). El chivo expiatorio. Anagrama. Barcelona.

Girard, R. (2005). La violencia y lo sagrado. Anagrama. Barcelona.

Grassi, E. (1999). Vico y el humanismo: ensayos sobre Vico, Heidegger y la retórica. Anthropos editorial. Barcelona.

Grassi, E. (2015). Retórica como filosofía: la tradición humanista. Anthropos editorial. Barcelona.

Julissa Mantilla (8 de marzo, 2016). El estereotipo de la “víctima propiciatoria”. Ius 360. Recuperado en https://ius360.com/columnas/el-estereotipo-de-la-victima-propiciatoria2/

Kermode, F. (2000). El sentido de un final. Gedisa. Barcelona.

Lorenz, F. (2006). Las guerras por Malvinas. Edhasa. Buenos Aires.

Moriarty, L. (2008). Controversies in Victimology. Mathew Bender & Company. Newark.

Partner, N. & Foot, S. (2013). Historical Theory. Sage Publication Ltd., Los Angeles-London.

Pepper, S. (1942). World Hypotheses. University of California Press. California.

Pitch, T. (2009). La sociedad de la prevención. Ad-Hoc editorial. Buenos Aires.

Salvi, V. (2012). De vencedores a víctimas. Memorias militares sobre el pasado reciente en la Argentina. Biblos. Buenos Aires.

Skinner, Q. (2007). Lenguaje, política e historia. Universidad Nacional de Quilmes. Bernal.

Tiburi, M. (2015). ¿Cómo conversar con un fascista? Reflexiones sobre al autoritarismo de la vida cotidiana. Akal. España.

Tozzi, V. (2012). The Epistemic and Moral Role of Testimony. History and Theory. Vol. 51. No. 1. 1-17.

Victim (s.f). En Online Etymology Dictionary. Recuperado de https://www.etymonline.com

Victim (s.f.). En Keyword project. Recuperado de http://keywords.pitt.edu/keywords_defined/victim.html

White, H. (2010). Metahistoria. La imaginación histórica del siglo XIX. FCE. México.

Williams, R. (1983). Keywords. A Vocabulary of Culture and Society. Segunda edición. Oxford University Press. New York.

Published

2020-08-18

How to Cite

Alejandro Murad, O. (2020). The figure of the victim: genealogy and argumentative uses. Prometeica - Journal of Philosophy and Science, 21, 35-46. https://doi.org/10.34024/prometeica.2020.21.10257
Received 2020-02-10
Accepted 2020-04-06
Published 2020-08-18